Friday, July 25, 2014

Review: The Goaltenders' Union (2014)

By Greg Oliver & Richard Kamchen

Goaltenders used to be a different species. It takes a certain type of person to be able to stand in front of 18,000 people with the job of not making a mistake. And then, when a mistake is made, those same 18,000 people either cheer with enthusiasm (a goalie's road games) or become emotionally crushed (home games).

Goalies have come up with all sorts of ways to handle that pressure, and some of the methods have been, um, unusual. They developed a reputation for odd behavior along the way. When one of those quirks comes up, hockey people have a funny way of mentioning it. They simply shrug their shoulders and say, "He's a union member."

That has nothing to do with the Players Association. It has everything to do with "The Goaltenders' Union," an informal way of referring to goalies as a strange group.

Greg Oliver and Richard Kamchen wrote a book on hockey goons a while back - that's another interesting subset of the hockey business - and they have returned with "The Goaltenders' Union."

This follows a rather simple formula. There's an introductory chapter on the subject of goaltending that covers a rather wide range of areas, including coaching. The idea of assistant coaches who concentrate on goaltending is relatively new, by the way. Then the book slides mostly into a series of biographies of goaltenders over the years.

Here's where the story turns a little odd. There's not much of a unifying theme about what goaltenders are selected for inclusions here. So, this isn't a book about an arbitrary list of the greatest goalies of all time, or 300-game winners, or whatever. It's just biographies of goalies, one after another, linked mostly by era. I believe there's a reference in the book that the authors talked to about 60 goalies along the way, and that sounds about right.

But what 60? Any goalie that played a decent amount of time might come up, and they do. So there's plenty of information here about players who don't have much historical significance, or who might not have had fascinating experiences along the way. So we hear from, say, Les Binkley and Bob Essensa, and not Curtis Joseph and Mike Vernon.

The authors add a few quotes from other sources, mostly newspapers and books, but those quotes don't provide too much perspective in some cases. The only criticism of the goalies usually comes from the goalie himself, which tends to turn the biographies rather vanilla.

I also noticed a couple of factual errors along the way. I received an early proof of this book, so typos about Jim Lorentz and Joel Quenneville may have been fixed in the printed copy. But saying Dominik Hasek was traded because of a salary crunch with the Sabres is simply wrong; he asked to be traded and tried to pick out a landing spot - finding one in Detroit. That makes it a little easy to worry about the accuracy of other, less familiar portions of the book, although each goalie does receive a quite adequate recap of his career.

Those looking for an overview of the people that have played the position certainly will find it with "The Goaltenders' Union." There are even some good stories about the characters who have filled the job at times. But the lack of some sort of unifying theme and perspective drag this down a couple of notches.

Two stars

Learn more about this book.

Be notified of new posts via Twitter @WDX2BB.

Thursday, July 17, 2014

Review: Idiots Revisited (2014)

By Ian Browne

Books looking back on championship teams are a staple of the sports publishing business. The facts of the season are usually well-known to the audience, so it's just a matter of reminding everyone what happened. Then a few new stories and updates are added.

In other words, these books can either be "phoned in" or new information can be collected that adds great insight into what happened ... or anything in between.

"Idiots Revisited" is definitely one of the very good ones in the field.

Author Ian Browne, a reporter for, went back and talked to several members of the Boston Red Sox organization from 2004, when the team ended an 86-year drought to win a World Series. They came through for him as Browne adds several new tales about that fairy tale season.

It's impressive just how honest and open several players and other officials were. One of the good things about a book like this is that some of the role players can supply a lot of perspective on what happen. Here, Gabe Kapler and Dave Roberts fill their jobs nicely. But Johnny Damon is almost painfully honest about what took place, and Curt Schilling. Pedro Martinez, Derek Lowe and Trot Nixon chip in with some very interesting comments. You'd expect Kevin Millar to do plenty of talking in a book like this, but the ever-quiet Mark Bellhorn even makes a solid contribution. Others chip in as well. Browne even gets Nomar Garciaparra to open up about the circumstances of his trade.

There's plenty of fascinating stuff here. Damon says the concussion he suffered in the fall of 2003 not only bothered him for the 2004 season, but for many years after that. Schilling talks about how he first hurt his ankle in spring training in 2004; you might recall that he did more damage in the postseason that year. Schilling also mentions how he got into a couple of mild fights with Manny Ramirez, while others talk about how difficult it was to keep Manny in line that season ... but they managed it for the most part. Keith Foulke was particularly driven to keep pitching in 2004's postseason, because he was going through a divorce and was no hurry to start a long winter in an empty house. Manager Terry Francona and general manager Theo Epstein also supply some thoughts and anecdotes.

For the most part, Browne is smart enough to get out of their way. He sets up situations with background information, and let's the players talk about the season - from spring training to that last ground ball to Foulke in the World Series. He also adds an epilogue about the fate of those players after 2004, which again features plenty of honesty.

It's hard to believe that "Idiots Revisited" could be done any better. OK, fans probably wouldn't have minded it the story was even longer - the 220 or so pages go by mighty quickly. "Idiots Revisited"  thus is an ideal read for Red Sox fans who want to look back on a magical year.

Five stars

Learn more about this book.

Be notified of new posts via Twitter @WDX2BB.

Monday, July 14, 2014

Review: Season of Saturdays (2014)

By Michael Weinred

Here's a lesson about jumping to conclusions when it comes to books.

"Season of Saturdays" looks rather straight-forward in its cover description. Michael Weinreb must have picked out the most important 14 games in college football history, and then thoroughly reviewed them in the book.

That's not quite what we have here. Luckily, it's probably better this way.

Weinreb has bigger things in mind. He essentially points to important trends in the game's history, and then picks out milestone games to prove his point. There isn't much play-by-play involved in the game descriptions. In fact, sometimes the game is beside the point, and that gets into a lively discussion about the sport.

For example, the Jan. 1, 1962 Rose Bowl matched Minnesota and UCLA. The game really didn't matter in one sense. What mattered is that Ohio State was the Big Ten champion that year, and passed up the chance to participate in the game. You can imagine how that went over with then-coach Woody Hayes. That's not happening now, not with the economics involved.

It is all part of the argument that has been part of college football for generations, and stays with us to this day. Should institutions of higher learning be involved in this level of athletics? Is it keeping with the mission statement of the college or university? Probably not, especially considering the fact that most schools lose money on athletics, and many have broken rules involving academic integrity in order to win football games.

Yet Weinred still finds the sport itself thrilling. He's feeling a little guilty about that, but not too much. It's partly because football serves a great connection between a university, the students, alumni and the surrounding city/town. Weinred grew up around Penn State, so he knows something about that subject. It's also because the games can be so darn exciting.

There are plenty of interesting aspects to the story told here. A subplot is the entire "Who is No. 1?" argument that has been a part of the game since, well, forever. One is the 1984 Orange Bowl featuring Nebraska and Miami. You might remember that Nebraska came within a point of tying the game in the final seconds. A tie, still possible in those days, would have given Nebraska the national championships in the polls. But Tom Osborne went for the win, and failed. It remains a fascinating decision, just like Notre Dame's action to accept the tie against Michigan State in 1966..

Then there's the curious case of Texas-Arkansas in 1969, when President Nixon announced that the winner of the game would be the nation's best team - even though Penn State was just as undefeated as the other two teams. Weinreb hints that politics might have had a roll in that move; there was an election to be won in 1972, after all.

The book goes in other directions from there. The author points to the Miami teams of the 1980s as ones that did whatever it wanted on and off the field, breaking the mold in that area. Then there's the rise of the passing game involving coaches such as Mike Leach and Steve Spurrier, who used the pass to set up the run instead of the other way around.

Finally, there's the unpredictable nature of the game, best shown by Auburn-Alabama last year. Alabama's coach was/is Nick Saban, master of taking as many variables out of the game as possible and perhaps the best college football coach ever. Even he couldn't compensate for the moment when an Auburn player ran a missed field goal back more than 100 yards for a game-winning touchdown on the final play of the game. Those moments, and there have been a lot of them, have made the sport special.

Weinred has clearly done his homework, and he never comes off as an apologist for the game. It's short but generally to the point. You might not like the personal stories about Penn State, but they work pretty well here. "Season of Saturdays" is a worthwhile read as we get ready for another season.

Four stars

Learn more about this book.

Be notified of new posts via Twitter @WDX2BB.